I would say super winch is better than smittybuilt, but not quite a warn or Ramsey. They have been around for a long time, but I haven't ever got to work with one. 9500 is overkill for your 2 door, so I'd say do it! Have you done some winch homework? Do you know if that's a good price?
05 Tj, long arm, one ton, lockers, winches, 39.5" Iroks