Lone Star - Missed your intro thread, but welcome from another resident in Johnson County!
I debated for a while between the Evo leveling kit and Rancho 9000 shocks, and getting the Rancho 2" sport lift, as they both offer the same lift, with the Rancho kit coming with bump stops up front, and extended brake link brackets. I too intend on going to a bigger lift with 37s, but that will come down the road. My alignment is a little off with the lift, so I may step into some lower control arms in the future to get it better, but it drover well on the trip (and around town) without them.
I am pretty happy with the Rancho lift, though if I were doing it again I would order the 2 door kit for the taller rear spacer (and I will probably order a taller spacer for the rear eventually). The 4 door kit has a 3/4" spacer, 2 door version has 1 3/4" rear spacer. With the extra weight of the bigger tire/wheel it wasnt too bad, but with the extra 100+lbs from the LOD rear bumper, I think I want it a little taller in the back.
Went to Colorado last week, and before we left I trimmed my rear fenders as they looked like they would rub, but I didnt have time to trim the fronts. Turns out, the fronts just got into my fenders going down Black Bear a little bit, but no rubbing anywhere else (315/70/17 Duratracs). Maybe Sunday I will get those trimmed, but maybe not...
I believe the Rancho 2" kit can be found for around $450-500 right now with the 9000 series shocks, and about $250-300 for the 5000 series shocks.
With "Shocktober" going on, I think you will spend around $275 for a set of shocks, so the cost is pretty close.
http://wayalife.com/showthread.php?25677-I-guess-its-time
Build thread is not updated with some changes yet, that will come soon enough. But as mentioned, the tummy tuck isnt a thing for JK, but in the thread I also have some pics of the Evo skid plate system, you can see how little is hanging down under there.