I've had both. Definitely advantages and disadvantages to both.
My TJ had a soft top. It was used all seasons. It was great when the boys were small. I'd just unzip the side windows and roll down the back and they could jump in without even opening the door. It was fun watching it turn into a balloon with the heat fan blowing. Also kept the noise down. It certainly is noisier than the hard top.
My 2009 JKR and 2016 JKUR had/have a hard top. I used to take the hard top off the 09 and put on a safari top with the duster and tonneau cover. Looked like a Brute or Pick up.
If I had both hard and soft tops, I'd use them both. Hard top for winter and soft top for summer.
I would not get rid of one simply because I had the other.
I will add that what ever soft top I had, I rarely rolled the top all the way back. The sun and wind can be brutal.
I'd take the doors and side panels off but generally left the top on.
Sent from my SM-G930V using
WAYALIFE mobile app