I had the first wheel you listed above, the ProComp LaPaz for 3.5 years and 73,000 miles. Went through all kinds of off road trails, scuffed them up, touched them up and they still worked great. I sold them when I went with D60s with a different bolt pattern. Now I have ATX Slabs. Procomp LaPaz is about $170 and ATX Slabs are about $400 each, so IMO you need to decide what your budget is and if you are going to go to D60s (or something with a different bolt pattern) any time soon? Slabs are much stronger, but not many tire shops will mount them or balance them from what I have seen. This was not an issue for me since I mounted mine myself and found a shop to balance them, but you need to consider that aspect IMO in your decision making process.