Have you looked at the standard ones available from jeep? I got them a few months ago, and haven't been disappointed.
When I first got my jeep, I ordered a set of mopar ones. By far the coolest looking and made of the best material (rubber.) The only problem is, they didn't do sh!t when it came to containing water. They have no lips around the outside. They are replacement floormats, not all weather mats IMHO. Huskyliners have the same problem...not enough lip. I used my mopars for a day and ordered the quadratecs.
OP, your choice is AEV mats, Quadratec mats, or Weathertec mats. I run the Qtecs and have been very happy with them. The AEVs seem to look the same but with a different design. Weathertec is good too, but their compound is harder than the other two...meaning, they feel slightly more like plastic and a little less like rubber.
P.S. Quadratec, and Rugged Ridge (and a few other brands) are all the same mat with a different badge on em.