Page 2 of 149 FirstFirst 12341252102 ... LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 1485

Thread: Roof Rack + Snorkel = Overland?

  1. #11
    Knows a Thing or Two RDE2ROK's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Location
    Wittmann AZ.
    Posts
    757
    WOW! What a topic. I think it just comes down to what you want to do. I have an RV to trailer my jeep to far away trips. I camp in a campground and wheel the area for 2-3 days. I sleep in my bed,have a shower and a good meal and my own restroom, I am out to enjoy myself and have a good time.Now that being said, I also have a roof rack to pack all the necessary supplies to go on a trip such as the Rubicon Trail. I don't want to be restricted to a certain type of trail.I want my jeep to be flexable. I realy like Rack Crawlin, but also "so called" expidition trails to sight see,explore and just have fun.So it just comes down to your own interpretation. If I want to do it! I want my jeep to take me there! Thats just my thoughts!
    Last edited by RDE2ROK; 03-24-2012 at 02:43 AM.
    IT'S JUST AN "X"

  2. #12
    Old Timer GCM 2's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Location
    Scottsdale, AZ
    Posts
    3,917
    Taken directly from "The Overland Journal",which is viewed as the predominant expert source for overlanding

    About Overlanding

    Overlanding is about exploration, rather than conquering obstacles. While the roads and trails we travel might be rough or technically challenging, they are the means to an end, not the goal itself. The goal is to see and learn about our world, whether on a weekend trip 100 miles from home or a 10,000-mile expedition across another continent. The vehicle and equipment can be simple or extravagant - they, too, are simply means to an end. History, wildlife, culture, scenery, self-sufficiency - these are the rewards of overlanding.


    From this definition alone, I can use a compact rental car for overlanding. I have gotten the feeling from guys who build "overland" specific rigs that there is some mystical thing that separates their "overland rig" from my build, which they consider to be a rock crawler.

    This I know as a fact; my JK can go everywhere an "overland rig" can go, but an "overland rig" cannot go everywhere my rig can go. I'll go with my build. And one last thing, we use to call it camping. Thanks for your time.
    2009 Black Rubicon Unlimited
    EVO Long Arm w/Envy Links
    EVO Front Double Throw Down
    EVO Lever Rear w/Double Throw Down
    Dynatrac Pro Rock 60's f/r
    PSC hydraulic ram assist
    Mastercraft Baja RS seats
    J.E. Reel 1350 drive shafts
    ATX Slab wheels
    40" Nitto Mud Grapplers

  3. #13
    Living the WAYALIFE MTG's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2012
    Location
    Reno eNVy
    Posts
    13,638
    Quote Originally Posted by GCM 2

    This I know as a fact; my JK can go everywhere an "overland rig" can go, but an "overland rig" cannot go everywhere my rig can go...And one last thing, we use to call it camping.
    Good stuff right there!

  4. #14
    Word Ninja Sharkey's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Location
    Nevada
    Posts
    11,723
    Quote Originally Posted by GCM 2
    This I know as a fact; my JK can go everywhere an "overland rig" can go, but an "overland rig" cannot go everywhere my rig can go. I'll go with my build. And one last thing, we use to call it camping. Thanks for your time.
    Yep...that pretty much sums it up.
    Jeep parts and accessories purchased through the following link will help support this forum and at no cost to you.
    RECOMMENDED JEEP PARTS & ACCESSORIES

  5. #15
    Knows a Thing or Two RDE2ROK's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Location
    Wittmann AZ.
    Posts
    757
    This I know as a fact; my JK can go everywhere an "overland rig" can go, but an "overland rig" cannot go everywhere my rig can go. I'll go with my build. And one last thing, we use to call it camping. Thanks for your time.
    Well Said!
    IT'S JUST AN "X"

  6. #16
    Hooked zeddjb's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Location
    Wisconsin
    Posts
    169

    Lightbulb What I think...

    Quote Originally Posted by GCM 2 View Post

    From this definition alone, I can use a compact rental car for overlanding. I have gotten the feeling from guys who build "overland" specific rigs that there is some mystical thing that separates their "overland rig" from my build, which they consider to be a rock crawler.

    This I know as a fact; my JK can go everywhere an "overland rig" can go, but an "overland rig" cannot go everywhere my rig can go. I'll go with my build. And one last thing, we use to call it camping. Thanks for your time.
    Good stuff GCM!!

    I agree with you, my JK can also go everywhere an "overland rig" can go. All mystics aside though, does it really matter how people look at off roading? What I mean is, Rock-Crawlers, Overlanders, Mud-Boggers or Dune Buggies we all have our "vision" of what off roading is and it's that vision that binds us all together. I can sum up it up in one phrase and Eddie can flame for for stealing it but, "It's a way of life"...Period!! I don't think it can be said any better.

    You guys are awesome

  7. #17
    Been Around the Block Indefatigable's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Location
    BC Canada
    Posts
    309
    As someone from a much more wild and less developed nation than America.... America is just a bit too much developed with infastructure to partake in the more idea of overland or as we are more akin to call it, expedition.

    You guys have done a great job creating recreational infastructure throughout your nation such that its not such a monumental undertaking for many and alot of experiences are achieveable for a huge proportion of your population. You have no idea how great your maps are!

    Some of the major build differences we see between an expedition vehicle and rock crawler....

    Gearing is more stock.
    No armour
    Usually runs a smaller tire.
    Usually not a Jeep. More likely a LC, p/u or roomier vehicle. Though this is changing a bit with the JKU.
    Our significantly less disposable income and higher cost of living probably is part of the slow accepance of the $$$$ JK compared to the more acceptably priced used trucks for these purposes.

    An expedition type trip a few of us have been talking about is "The Canol Trail" . Starts at the Yukon border and heads NE. I think maybe 50% is driveable. The trail actually ends on the wrong side of the MacKenzie River at Norman Wells.

    YMMV
    05 LJ - Hi-Lo-2nd Lo- Stupid Lo
    Herd of Turtles 4WD Society

  8. #18
    Administrator wayoflife's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Location
    Carson City, NV
    Posts
    51,316
    Quote Originally Posted by MTG View Post
    Built for overland = install an AEV lift?

    no kidding. more times than not, that's what it seems like

    Quote Originally Posted by Sharkey View Post
    I'm not sure what "overland" is supposed to mean either. Particularly here in the states, I think the more appropriate term would be a "wilderness" Jeep. To me, travel in the wilderness requires many things the most important of which are (1) the ability to self-rescue because of the inability to obtain assistance or reach civilization in less than one day's hike and (2) self-sustenance without the need for re-ration or support (food, water, equipment, etc.) from civilization for the period of time traveled.

    Depending on your mode of travel, and the topography of what is to be traveled, the gear you bring to satisfy (1) and (2) above will obviously change. I fail to see how having a flip-top tent on the roof of a Jeep makes it more wilderness capable than another Jeep that has a 4-season tent or bivy sack stored in a bag in the back. Actually, I can think of many reasons why the latter would be a MUCH better way to go than the former. (If your Jeep becomes inoperable in the wilderness, it's pretty hard to carry your flip top tent on your back to use as shelter on your multi-day hike out...oh, and there is that whole weight savings thing.) I also fail to see how a Jeep with 35's and a standard lift is somehow more wilderness capable than a Jeep turning 40's with coilovers. The only argument I could see is if the distance traveled is so great that the relative difference in gas mileage becomes an issue which cannot be planned for through preparation (i.e. bringing extra gas). Here in the states though (particularly the lower 48), that problem seems unlikely.

    I guess my point is that "overland" has become more of a cliche for a type of look and less of a definition of capabilities. If your Jeep is built to cover the terrain you plan to cover, and you have the ability to fix it and perform self-rescue, then the rest really comes down to what else you throw in the back and what you have between your ears, not how the Jeep was built. Just my .02.
    Wow, that was well said and, I'd have to agree with you 100%. I've never given it much thought until recently but, I really am starting to see the term "overland" as a cliche for a type of look and less of a definintion of capabilities. At least, I have yet to see or hear how people here in America who profess to have an "overland built" have a Jeep that is anymore capable than mine or most anyone elses built up Jeep.

  9. #19
    Administrator wayoflife's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Location
    Carson City, NV
    Posts
    51,316
    Quote Originally Posted by JKRay View Post
    I always thought overland was jeeps that took on open spaces, like the plains and meadows or like the outback in Australia that is what an overland jeep is to me. Just my
    granted, this is a shot of moby's clone and moochie's JK but, we do a lot of exploring in open spaces like plains and meadow too



    Quote Originally Posted by zeddjb View Post
    I would be curious to know WOL, how this question came to be. I know you said the topic came up, but was there a valid argument on the topic or was is just, "Hey I heard this somewhere..." kind of thing?
    actually, the question has been coming up more and more recently and mostly with guys running kits like what AEV makes. their argument is that there's actually some kind of difference between an "overland" lift kit and what i have and that not everyone needs or wants a "rock crawler". of course, if you've ever riden in a JK with both setups, i think you would agree that my so called "rock crawler" not only far exceeds the performance of other short arm kits or ones that use relocation brackets off road but, it also far exceeds the performance in terms of ride and handly on pavement too. but hey, that's just me.

    Quote Originally Posted by Sharkey View Post
    I can't speak for WOL, but I can say I've read numerous comments where people discount advice about lifts on the basis that "they are building an overland Jeep, not a rock crawler" without ever taking the time to explain what they view as a legitimate distinction between the two. If they were talking about purpose built buggies then I might understand the point, but a JKU on coilovers seems every bit as capable to me as an "overlander", if not more so, than any other JKU build.
    exactly. if there really is a difference in how you build an "overland" jeep, i'd like to know what it is and why it's so much better than a jeep like mine.

    Quote Originally Posted by JKRay View Post
    Just thinking now the overland vehicles started in places like Africa or Australia to keep safe from dangerous animals like lions. The tent on top is to stay safe from snakes, lions and other dangers that can get to them if they were on the ground. The snorkel to cross rivers or creeks without killing the engine. Its really to stay safe from what is surrounding them and get out of crap to get home nothing else.
    yeah, if i needed to ford really really deep water, a snorkel would be a must but, i can tell you from seeing it first hand, if you did ford water that deep in a JK, you would seriously screw up things like your seatbelts. once wet, they won't work anymore. also, compared to most overland jeeps i've seen, our moby sits SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER than them and because of it, never dunk down deep enough to need one. as far as sitting up high or carrying more supplies, i might prefer a trailer over a roof rack. we've done the roof rack thing on our old TJ as it really was the only way to haul in enough gear for 3 people and a dog but, i really really hated wheeling with it as it totally screws up your center of gravity and gets hung up in trees.

    Quote Originally Posted by RDE2ROK View Post
    WOW! What a topic. I think it just comes down to what you want to do. I have an RV to trailer my jeep to far away trips. I camp in a campground and wheel the area for 2-3 days. I sleep in my bed,have a shower and a good meal and my own restroom, I am out to enjoy myself and have a good time.Now that being said, I also have a roof rack to pack all the necessary supplies to go on a trip such as the Rubicon Trail. I don't want to be restricted to a certain type of trail.I want my jeep to be flexable. I realy like Rack Crawlin, but also "so called" expidition trails to sight see,explore and just have fun.So it just comes down to your own interpretation. If I want to do it! I want my jeep to take me there! Thats just my thoughts!
    well, exploring is our true love and what ultimately got us into wheeling in the first place. we've only built up our rigs to help ensure we can get to our planned destination.

  10. #20
    Administrator wayoflife's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Location
    Carson City, NV
    Posts
    51,316
    Quote Originally Posted by GCM 2 View Post
    From this definition alone, I can use a compact rental car for overlanding. I have gotten the feeling from guys who build "overland" specific rigs that there is some mystical thing that separates their "overland rig" from my build, which they consider to be a rock crawler.

    This I know as a fact; my JK can go everywhere an "overland rig" can go, but an "overland rig" cannot go everywhere my rig can go. I'll go with my build. And one last thing, we use to call it camping. Thanks for your time.
    wow, that was perfect and, i couldn't have said it better if i tried.

    Quote Originally Posted by zeddjb View Post
    I agree with you, my JK can also go everywhere an "overland rig" can go. All mystics aside though, does it really matter how people look at off roading? What I mean is, Rock-Crawlers, Overlanders, Mud-Boggers or Dune Buggies we all have our "vision" of what off roading is and it's that vision that binds us all together. I can sum up it up in one phrase and Eddie can flame for for stealing it but, "It's a way of life"...Period!! I don't think it can be said any better.
    that's the way i've always seen it and when i started to hear this rhetoric about "overland built" jeeps, i just had to stop and ask, what is the difference? to me, a well built jeep is a well built jeep and i unless i'm wrong, i thought that's what we all wanted.

    Quote Originally Posted by Indefatigable View Post
    As someone from a much more wild and less developed nation than America.... America is just a bit too much developed with infastructure to partake in the more idea of overland or as we are more akin to call it, expedition.

    You guys have done a great job creating recreational infastructure throughout your nation such that its not such a monumental undertaking for many and alot of experiences are achieveable for a huge proportion of your population. You have no idea how great your maps are!

    Some of the major build differences we see between an expedition vehicle and rock crawler....

    Gearing is more stock.
    No armour
    Usually runs a smaller tire.
    Usually not a Jeep. More likely a LC, p/u or roomier vehicle. Though this is changing a bit with the JKU.
    Our significantly less disposable income and higher cost of living probably is part of the slow accepance of the $$$$ JK compared to the more acceptably priced used trucks for these purposes.

    An expedition type trip a few of us have been talking about is "The Canol Trail" . Starts at the Yukon border and heads NE. I think maybe 50% is driveable. The trail actually ends on the wrong side of the MacKenzie River at Norman Wells.

    YMMV
    and, that is why i specifically asked the question in the way that i did - "in america". maybe if we were up in the yukon, africa, south america or the gobi desert, i might see where building a rig with specilized parts would be a disadvantage as things replacement parts would be hard, if not impossible to come by but, here in america, i kind of find the idea of purposefully building a so called "overland" jeep to not make a whole lot of sense. more times than not, the only real difference i see is that they have a jeep with a sub-standard suspension system, a roof rack and snorkel.

Page 2 of 149 FirstFirst 12341252102 ... LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
About us
“wayoflife” is a moniker that I’ve been using for 20 years now and I chose it because I think it does a great job of explaining, in simple terms, the passion I have for Jeeps and the Jeep way of life. This is a lifestyle that transcends age, gender and race as the only thing you need to be a part of it is a love for the outdoors, a desire to explore, a yearning to take on a challenge and a will to conquer it. Over the years, Cindy and I have attempted to capture the essence of this lifestyle through photographs and videos and share it with others around the world. And, this is how WAYALIFE was born.
Join us
WATCH OUR VIDEOS