I have a G2 44 up front on my jk sport and I love it.
That's cool that you "love" something that you chose to buy. I mean, it would totally suck to spend thousands of dollars on something that you didn't. But, saying that you "love" something you chose to buy is a far cry from the invaluable "trail experience" the OP was asking for or at least, in my opinion.
I have a 5 year unlimited mile warranty to replace anything that breaks no questions asked with them. I had to pay 750 extra for it.
Maybe it's just me but, the best warranty is the one you never have to use let alone have to pay for extra but again, that's just me.
I know some are loyal to brands but mine came down to price and hassle.
You'll forgive me but you don't need brand loyalty to want to buy something that's been proven to work and be the best time and time again. And, when you buy the best, it comes at a price. Everything else is just cheaper.
I would say look at both and price both. I've heard of PR going for as low as 5500? (Correct me if I'm wrong on that) but I got quoted over 7k for it. With everything else I was doing I couldn't afford it at the time.
To be fair, you also got quoted and sold on a $750 warranty on an axle that's "supposed" to be as good as a ProRock. Also, if I got quoted $7k for a ProRock, I would have looked for a different vendor to buy from but hey, that's just me.