Eddie, I get what you are saying that ride quality is subjective. I would like to add another element to the equation though. That there is a certain lack of reference for people who subjectively state that THEIR ride is "nice". I see so many arguments that are made that are from self-fulfilling positions. The idea that "the ride that I bought is the best ride."
I believe that most people have not had a chance to really test these suspension systems against others in a relatively controlled environment. I believe that they made a choice based on budget, prior experience, perceptions, and general emotions. Rarely do I see people make a purchase decision based on objective testing, or even subjective testing. In my case, I took it on blind faith that what you guys were talking about was accurate. So far I am happy with the decision. But am I also self fulfilling myself into my own decision?
I have yet to have someone tell me that they felt that the EVO Double Throw Down Suspension system was worse than XXX suspension system. Maybe this is just my lack of experience in the field, which I admit is substantial. Or maybe the person who just drove my Jeep was fearful of being offensive to me if they told me anything different. On the contrary, I would welcome comments. Or maybe they simply hate to admit that any given suspension system is better than theirs. The biggest complaint I get from passers by is the idea that I "spent too much" or "just the shocks alone cost more than my entire lift". Frankly, I am not too concerned. I have only driven a stock Jeep, 3 lifted Jeeps and my own. I just cannot see how I could subjectively say that those lifts were better in most aspects. I did find that one lift, for the given trail that we were on at the time, felt better at low speeds. But then, am I also falling victim to my own perceived notions of a prior purchase?
It just begs the question, is there some form of objective testing available to the consumer that can help them make a better decision? Would there be a way to objectively cut through the bullshit and get to the facts regarding ride quality?
Whatever the case may be, I am finding that in general the more money you put into a suspension upgrade will net you a better ride. Don't you agree?