notnalc68
That dude from Mississippi
Best advice in this whole thread. Although WJCO's experiment is hysterical.
Sent from my duck blind.
Wonder what his science projects in school were like.
Sent from my iPhone using WAYALIFE mobile app
Best advice in this whole thread. Although WJCO's experiment is hysterical.
Sent from my duck blind.
Ok to summarize...
I need to sleeve truss and gusset my PR44 so when I stick it in my butthole it won't bend when I pull on it?
Ok got it!
Sent from my iPhone using WAYALIFE mobile app
WHY sleeve and truss it when you are just going to bitch MORE when it fails anyway. :idontknow:
"$200" for these magic "hammer- in" sleeves
$250 for a truss kit
$800 in labor for someone to pull the front axle and POSSIBLY hammer in the magics
$1000 for someone to prep and weld in the truss.
You arer at $2,250 of WASTED MONEY and for about $30 more, you could have actually upgraded to a PR44 housing... this thread is retarded.
:beer:
Ok to summarize...
I need to sleeve truss and gusset my PR44 so when I stick it in my butthole it won't bend when I pull on it?
Ok got it!
Sent from my iPhone using WAYALIFE mobile app
Best advice in this whole thread. Although WJCO's experiment is hysterical.
Sent from my duck blind.
make sure you pull down and out and not up and over. gotta ge the knuckle at the right angle :thumb:
/threadWHY sleeve and truss it when you are just going to bitch MORE when it fails anyway. :idontknow:
"$200" for these magic "hammer- in" sleeves
$250 for a truss kit
$800 in labor for someone to pull the front axle and POSSIBLY hammer in the magics
$1000 for someone to prep and weld in the truss properly.
You are at $2,250 of WASTED MONEY and for about $30 more, you could have actually upgraded to a PR44 housing... this thread is retarded.
[emoji481]
Just to play the devil part
I do not disagree with you but...
Sleeves and Gussets can be had for about $100 dry ice is fun to play with and will help with installation. Weld your own gussets on your D30 just for fun and practice same with the truss if you want, I think you can find one of those for about $100 as well. The you get all that experience and fun of working on your Jeep and save some money( or waste it building a D30 depending on how you look at it)
Save that other money for when it breaks...
Sent from my iPhone using WAYALIFE mobile app
Just to play the devil part
I do not disagree with you but...
Sleeves and Gussets can be had for about $100 dry ice is fun to play with and will help with installation. Weld your own gussets on your D30 just for fun and practice same with the truss if you want, I think you can find one of those for about $100 as well. The you get all that experience and fun of working on your Jeep and save some money( or waste it building a D30 depending on how you look at it)
Save that other money for when it breaks...
Sent from my iPhone using WAYALIFE mobile app
Not ASSuming anything. Just making conversation.
As I said I don't disagree with you. Just a different thought. That's all.
Sent from my iPhone using WAYALIFE mobile app
WHY sleeve and truss it when you are just going to bitch MORE when it fails anyway. :idontknow:
"$200" for these magic "hammer- in" sleeves
$250 for a truss kit
$800 in labor for someone to pull the front axle and POSSIBLY hammer in the magics
$1000 for someone to prep and weld in the truss properly.
You are at $2,250 of WASTED MONEY and for about $30 more, you could have actually upgraded to a PR44 housing... this thread is retarded.
:beer:
Is the assumption that the individual couldn't install a $120 DIY hammer in sleeve their selves, but they could set up the R&P in the PR44 without incurring labor costs? Seems that the cost difference is a bit understated.
I'm reccomend sleeves that cost under 200$ and install in less than 2 hours, that's a lot more reasonable for most people, opposed to reccomending them to save up for a 5k axle
here is a trussed 3 link rear 44, as you can see, the axle was MUCH stronger! Much improved, Much Wow. :doh: :hmm: :cheesy:
The truss poorly attempts to mitigate 1 problem, but the axle still fails. in this specific case, the whole pumpkin rotated. :naw:
View attachment 243110
View attachment 243111
he would have to regear regardless of what he does about axle housings?? so that cost should be included in the comparison because...??? :daydream: :thinking: :hmm:
Still missing the point. The tube RARELY bends in the middle. It bends at the pumpkin. Therefore sleeves are useless. Also, your argument on hammer in sleeves really has no weight. Welding will ALWAYS be stronger. The point you are making is like saying a bolt on track bar bracket is stronger than a weld on bracket. It's retarded.They do though. Go get 2 straws, see how easy one bends, cut a slit in the second and "sleeve" it. You will feel a small difference. It's crazy to say that adding wall thickness doesn't help strength.. and I disagree about that hammer in sleeves, they actually provide more contact area than weld in ones do, the weld sleeves rely on the rosette weld areas for contact. And yes like you said a thicker diameter tubing is going to be strong than a thinner one with thicker walls. However that diameter only helps in a few different structural ways, not with impact. Take a look at the jk stock driveshafts, thin and big, but strong for torque, but will crush on a rock. Now look at a JE reel or Adams shaft, thinner diameter thicker wall.
Sent from my iPhone using WAYALIFE mobile app
Still missing the point. The tube RARELY bends in the middle. It bends at the pumpkin. Therefore sleeves are useless. Also, your argument on hammer in sleeves really has no weight. Welding will ALWAYS be stronger. The point you are making is like saying a bolt on track bar bracket is stronger than a weld on bracket. It's retarded.
You think a "hammer in" sleeve is going to net a compression fit? ...I hope you are joking...My original statements were about the tubes splitting after hitting something. Most axles I've seen bent were all at the C. And no it's nothing like a bolt or trackbar bracket. In regards to tubing it is usually always stronger to have a compression fit opposed to rosette welds. But I guess after years of working on hydraulic cranes and heavy equipment I'll just stick to the advice on here, thanks. And yes welding is stronger than simply bolting something on, I am talking about hammer in sleeves that are a machined fit and support the tubing not only at the welded locations. And yes everyone I understand sleeves will not stop axle failure!!!! But I do think that they help, no they will not prevent a bend at the center section. But installing sleeves and gussets for around 230$ it's not a bad idea. I have sleeves and gussets on my rubi 44, had a hard hit on a rock and broke off 4 brackets and bent the rest. The axle itself was still straight as an arrow.
Sent from my iPhone using WAYALIFE mobile app